Partisipasi Masyarakat Lokal Medan: Sebuah Tinjauan Atas Kriteria Nasional Pada Proses Penetapan Sebagai Cagar Budaya

Isnen Fitri


Among the important problems encountered in the implementation of cultural heritage preservation in Indonesia nowadays is the establishment of the cultural register in national, province, or regency/city levels. Criteria in article 5 of the Law on Items of Cultural Heritage No.11/2010 are insufficient for the process of assigning historical assets as cultural heritage items. The criteria also seem to merely be a “copy and paste” of the previous law. Meanwhile, at the global level, during the last several decades, many countries have begun to adopt the concept of the important values of heritages, which is depicted in the Burra Charter as a reference to develop criteria in assigning items of cultural heritages. To improve our national criteria in the near future, this study is aimed at evaluating national criteria in article 5 based on opinions of 33 representatives of local communities in Medan, as stakeholders in the preservation of cultural heritages in the city of Medan, by performing interviews and group discussions using Nominal Group Technique or NGT. From the diverse opinions of the 33 participants obtained from the two phases of data collecting process, it is concluded that our national criteria in assigning an item of cultural heritage that were mentioned in article 5 of the Law on Items of Cultural Heritage No.11/2010 are still obscure, difficult to measure, overlapping, and not quite in line with global trend. Most participants disagree that age is used as the main criteria. There are a number of suggestions (inputs) from the participants to improve the sentences in article 5 to form criteria that are easier to measure and independent.


national criteria; community involvement; Medan; tangible cultural heritage; heritage value

Full Text:



----------- 1975. “Declaration of Amsterdam”. Congress on the European Architectural Heritage. Amsterdam: Council of Europe.

------------ 2001. Participation in Development Assisstance. Washington D.C.: Operations Evaluation Social Development Study, World Bank.

A. Hornby. 2005. Oxford Advanced Learner's Dictionary, Seventh Edition: Oxford University Press

Azni Mohd Dian, and Nuraisyah Chua Abdullah. 2013. “Public Participation in Heritage Sites Conservation in Malaysia: Issues and Challenges.” Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 101:248--255.

Cheung, Peter T.Y. 2011. “Civic Engagement in the Policy Process in Hongkong: Change and Continuity”. Public Admin.Development 31:113--121.

Chirikure, Shadreck, and Gilbert Pwiti. 2008. “Community Involvement in Archaeology and Cultural Heritage Management: An Assessment from Case Studies in Southern Africa and Elsewhere”. Current Anthropology 49(3): 467--485.

Christina Aas, Adele Ladkin, and John Fletcher. 2005. “Stakeholder Collaboration And Heritage Management”. Annals of Tourism Research 32(1):28--48.

Gillham, Bill. 2007. Developing a questionnaire London: Continuum International Publishing Group.

Glendinning, Miles. 2003. “The Conservation Movement: A Cult of the Modern Age.” Transactions of the Royal Historical Society 13 (Sixth Series):359--376.

Gubrium, Jaber F. 2002. Handbook of wawancara research : context & method. Thousand Oaks, California: Sage Publications Inc.

Hennink, Monique, Inge Hutter, & Ajay Bailey. 2011. “Qualitative research methods”. Thousand Oaks, California: Sage Publications Inc.

Hobson, Edward. 2004. Conservation Planning. Changing Values in Policy and Practice. London: Spon Press.

Fitri, Isnen. 2013. “Assessment Criteria for Cultural Significance of Built Cultural Heritage of Medan”, Paper dipresentasikan pada Malaysia-Japan Conservation Research Colloquium, Tokyo-Kyoto.

Jokilehto, Jukka. 1998. “International Trends in Historic Preservation: From Ancient Monuments to Living Cultures”. APT Bulletin 29(3/4) Thirtieth-Anniversary Issue: 17--19.

Jokilehto, Jukka. 2008. “What is OUV? Defining the Outstanding Universal Value of Cultural World Heritage Properties”. Berlin: Hendrik Bäßler Verlag (Edited by ICOMOS).

Kementrian Pekerjaan Umum. Direktorat Penataan Ruang, & Badan Pelestarian Pusaka Indonesia. (2010). Kota Pusaka. Langkah Indonesia Membuka Mata Dunia. Jakarta: Kementrian Pekerjaan Umum. Direktorat Penataan Ruang.

Kerr, J. S. 2013. (The 7th Edition) Conservation Plan. A Guide to preparation plans for places of European Cultural Significance. Australia. AICOMOS.

Macdonald, Susan, and Caroline Cheong. 2014. The Role of Public-Private Partnerships and the Third Sector in Conserving Heritage Buildings, Sites, and Historic Urban Areas. Los Angeles: The Getty Conservation Institute.

Mason, Randall. 2002. Assessing Values in Conservation Planning: Methodological Issues and Choices. dalam Marta de la Torre (Ed.), Assessing the Values of Cultural Heritage (pp. p.5-30). Los Angeles: The Getty Conservation Institute.

Munoz-Vinas, Salvador. 2005. Contemporary Theory of Conservation. Oxford: Elsevier Butterworth-Heinemann.

Pusat Bahasa. 2008. Kamus Besar Bahasa Indonesia. Jakarta: Gramedia Pustaka Utama.

Shadreck Chirikure, and Gilbert Pwiti. 2008. “Community Involvement in Archaeology and Cultural Heritage Management: An Assessment from Case Studies in Southern Africa and Elsewhere”. Current Anthropology 49(3):467--485.

Tanudirjo, Daud Aris 2003. “Warisan Budaya Untuk Semua: Arah Kebijakan Pengelola Warisan Budaya Indonesia Di Masa Mendatang”. In Kongres Kebudayaan V. Bukittinggi.

Tanudirjo, Daud Aris 2010. “Undang-undang Cagar Budaya 2010 dalam perspektif arkeologi” Paper dipresentasikan pada Diskusi Pembahasan Undang-Undang tentang Cagar Budaya, Bogem, Sleman, Yogyakarta

Wutcher, Guy, and Frances B. Affandy. 1993. “Bandung Society for Heritage Conservation -a Case Study Illustrating the Involvement of an NGO for Heritage Management in Indonesia”. Paper presented at International Scientific Symposium on Cultural Tourism. 10th General Assembly, Colombo.

Zanchetti, S.M, and J. Jokilehto. 1997. “Values and urban conservation planning: some reflections on principles and defenitions”. Journal of Architectural Conservation 3(1):37-51.

Zancheti, S.M., Lúcia Tone Ferreira Hidaka, Cecilia Ribeiro, and Barbara Aguiar. 2009. "Judgement and Validation in the Burra Charter Process: Introducing Feedback in Assessing the Cultural Significance of Heritage Sites." City & Time 4 (2): 47--53.


AICOMOS. 1999. “Burra Charter.” Australia ICOMOS.

Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. "Gaining Consensus among Stakeholders through the Nominal Group Technique." Centers for Disease Control and Prevention Healthy Youth Evaluation Briefs No.7.

Pereira, Honório Nicholls. 2007. “Contemporary trends in conservation: culturalization, significance and sustainability”. City & Time 3(2):15--25,

UNESCO. 1976. “Nairobi Recommendation: International Recommendation concerning the Safeguarding and Contemporary Role of Historic Areas”.

Article Metrics

View Counter : Abstract | 192 | PDF | 10 | Total View | 222 |



  • There are currently no refbacks.

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.